Accra:Parliament The Portfolio Committee on Land Reform and Rural Development has adopted its preliminary Budgetary Review and Recommendation Report concerning the performance of the Department of Land Reform and Rural Development and its related entities. The committee acknowledged that the department's annual report and the report of the Commission on Restitution of Land Rights are yet to be fully audited and tabled, making the current findings provisional. A supplementary report will be provided once the audited results are available.
According to Parliament of South Africa, the financial performance of the department was found unsatisfactory. From a final appropriation of R10.468 billion, only R7.865 billion, or 75.1 percent, was spent, leaving R2.603 billion unutilized. Programme 3 Land Reform and Restitution accounted for R2.333 billion of the underspend, with over R2.28 billion in transfers and subsidies for restitution beneficiaries not used. The committee views this as a delay in constitutional redress rather than merely a financial management issue.
The department's non-financial performance was also reported as weak, achieving only 15 out of its 23 annual targets, the lowest in five years. Land Administration achieved 89 percent of its goals, while Land Reform and Restitution and Rural Development each reached only 60 percent, and Administration achieved 25 percent. Moreover, only 35,539 hectares were allocated against a target of 44,000, and 239 land claims were settled against a target of 281. Rural development saw 227 jobs created against a target of 450. Concerns were also raised about vacancies in senior positions, delayed organizational redesign, and late financial statement submissions.
The committee noted the Commission on Restitution of Land Rights spent R1.935 billion out of approximately R4.189 billion, leaving R2.254 billion unspent amidst ongoing claims backlogs. The Office of the Valuer-General's performance improved to 89 percent with all valuation requests completed and a clean audit achieved, though senior management vacancies remain an issue.
Concerns were raised regarding the Ingonyama Trust Board, which recorded R61.3 million in beneficiary disbursements and strong lease collection. However, the Trust received a qualified audit opinion, with 96 percent of debtors over 120 days old. The Agricultural Land Holdings Account reported assets of R16.9 billion but lease receivables of about R894.6 million and irregular expenditure over R1 billion.
The Deeds Registration Trading Entity was noted as financially healthy with R1.285 billion in revenue and a R285.5 million surplus, though progress on the electronic Deeds Registration System and rising receivables require attention. The committee concluded that challenges extend beyond funding to include institutional capacity to convert resources into measurable outcomes, with issues of under-expenditure, weak project implementation, and governance deficiencies.
Recommendations include a review of the land reform institutions' funding architecture by the Minister of Finance to align appropriations with delivery capacity and constitutional obligations. Additional allocations for restitution capacity gaps, Communal Property Associations support, and tenure reform were suggested. A dedicated conditional funding framework for the Integrated Land Reform and Rural Development Support Programme was recommended, alongside a multi-year funding assurance for ICT projects like the e-DRS.
Moreover, a review of the Agricultural Land Holdings Account financial model was advised, equitable access to land and communal land tenure legislation should be finalized, and the Ingonyama Trust Board's long-term funding model should be reassessed. The committee emphasized ongoing rigorous oversight to ensure funds benefit the intended recipients, with responses to recommendations expected within two months of the report's adoption.
Source Parliament of South Africa